The key questions addressed by this research were:
For this pilot study, we conducted 1- to 1-1/2-hour interviews with six elementary, middle, and high school teachers of science and math. These were open-ended interviews structured around a series of probes.
As we sought, through this research, to conduct an exploratory inquiry into the nature of the relationship between systematic approaches to instructional design and teachers' needs, our most significant and unexpected finding was that, from the teachers' perspective, caring must be a central component of any instructional design activity. Regardless of gender and grades taught, the teachers indicated that they need to be able to make instructional decisions based upon their caring relationships with individual learners, not upon the imperatives of an impersonal, systematic instructional design process.
Rose, E., & Tingley, K. (2008, Winter). Science and math teachers as instructional designers: Linking ID to the ethic of caring. Canadian Journal of Learning and Technology 34(1). (Accepted/Forthcoming).